How the Young Unity Health Score Company Handles The Dilemmas of Health IT Adoption

I have been talking to a young company called Unity Health Score with big plans for improving the collection and sharing of data on patients. Their 55-page business plans covers the recruitment of individuals to share health data, the storage of that data, and services to researchers, clinicians, and insurers. Along the way, Unity Health Score tussles with many problems presented by patient data.
Unity Health Score logo
The goals articulated for this company by founder Austin Jones include getting better data to researchers and insurers so they can reduce costs and find cures, improving communications and thus care coordination among clinicians and patients, and putting patients in control of their health data so they can decide where it goes. The multi-faceted business plan covers:

  • Getting permission from patients to store data in a cloud service maintained by Unity Health Score
  • Running data by the patients’ doctors to ensure accuracy
  • Giving patients control over what researchers or other data users receive their data, in exchange for monetary rewards
  • Earning revenue for the company and the patients by selling data to researchers and insurers
  • Helping insurers adjust their plans based on analysis of incoming data

The data collected is not limited to payment data or even clinical data, but could include a grab-bag of personal data, such financial and lifestyle information. All this might yield health benefits to analytics–after all, the strategy of using powerful modern deep learning is being pursued by many other health care entities. At the same time, Jones plans to ensure might higher quality data than traditional data brokers such as Acxiom.

Now let’s see what Unity Health Score has to overcome to meet its goals. These challenges are by no means unique to these energetic entrepreneurs–they define the barriers faced by institutions throughout health care, from the smallest start-up to the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services.

Outreach to achieve a critical mass of patients
We can talk for weeks about quality of care and modernizing cures, but everybody who works in medicine agrees that the key problem we face is indifference. Most people don’t want to think too much about their health, are apathetic when presented with options, and stubbornly resist the simplist interventions–even taking their prescribed medication. So explaining the long-term benefits of uploading data and approving its use will be an uphill journey.

Many app developers seek adoption by major institutions, such as large insurers, hospital conglomerates, and HMOs like Kaiser. This is the smoothest path toward adoption by large numbers of consumers, and Unity Health Score includes a similar plan in its business model, According to Jones, they will require the insurance company to reduce premiums based on each patient’s health score. In return, they should be able to use the data collected to save money.

Protecting patient data
Health data is probably the most sensitive information most of us produce over our lifetimes. Financial information is important to keep safe, but you can change your bank account or credit card if your financial information is leaked–you can’t change your medical history. Security and privacy guarantees are therefore crucial for patient records. Indeed, the Unity Health Score business plan cites fears of privacy as a key risk.

Although some researchers have tried distributed patient records, stored in some repository chosen by each individual, Unith Health Score opts for central storage, like most current personal health records. This not only requires great care to secure, but places on them the burden of persuading patients that the data really will be used only for purposes chosen by the patients. Too many apps and institutions play three-card Monte with privacy policies, slipping in unauthorized uses (just think back to the recent Facebook/Cambridge Analytica scandal), so Internet users have become hypervigilant.

Unity Health Score also has to sign up physicians to check data for accuracy. This, of course, should be the priority for any data entered into any medical record. Because doctors’ time is going more and more toward the frustrating task of data entry, the company offers an enticing trade-off: the patients takes the time to enter their data, and the doctor merely verifies its accuracy. Furthermore, a consolidated medical record online can be used to speed check-in times on visits and to make data sharing on mobile devices easier.

Making the data useful
Once the patients and clinicians join Unity Health Score, the company has to follow through on its promise. This is a challenge with multiple stages.

First, much of the data will be in unstructured doctors’ notes. Jones plans to use OCR, like many other health data aggregators, to extract useful information from the notes. OCR and natural language processing may indeed be more accurate than relying on doctors to meticulously fill out dozens of structured fields in a database. But there is always room for missed diagnoses or allergies, and even for misinterpretations.

Next, data sources must be harmonized. They are likely to use different units and different lexicons. Although many parts of the medical industry are trying to standardize their codings, progress is incomplete.

The notion of a single number defining one’s health is appealing, but it might be too crude for many uses. Whether you’re making actuarial predictions (when will the individual die, or have to stop working?), estimating future health care costs, or guessing where to allocate public health resources, details about conditions may be more important than an all-encompassing number. However, many purchasers of the Unity Health Score information may still find the simplicity of a single integer useful.

Making the service attractive to data purchasers
The business plan points out that most rsearch depends on large data sets. During the company’s ramp-up phase–which could take years–they just won’t have enough patients suffering from a particular condition to interest many researchers, such as pharma companies looking for subjects. However, the company can start by selling data to academic researchers, who often can accomplish a lot with a relatively small sample. Biotech, pharma, and agencies can sign up later.

Clinicians may warm to the service much more quickly. They will appreciate having easy access to patient data for emergency room visits and care coordination in general. However, this is a very common use case for patient data, and one where many competing services are vying for a business niche.

Aligning goals of stakeholders
In some ways I have saved the hardest dilemma for last. Unity Health Care is trying to tie together many sets of stakeholders–patients, doctors, marketers, researchers, insurers–and between many of these stakeholders there are irreconcilable conflicts.

For instance, insurers will want the health score to adjust their clients’ payments, charging more for sick people. This will be feared and resented by people with pre-existing conditions, who will therefore withhold their information. In some cases, such insurer practices will worsen existing disparities for the poor and underpriviledged. The Unity Health Score business plan rejects redlining, but there may be subtler practices that many observers would consider unethical. Sometimes, incentives can also be counterproductive.

Also, as the business plan points out, many companies that currently purchase health data have goals that run counter to good health: they want to sell doctors or patients products that don’t actually help, and that run up health care costs. Some purchasers are even data thieves. Unity Health Score has a superior business model here to other data brokers, because it lets the patients approve each distribution of their data. But doing so greatly narrows the range of purchasers. Hopefully, there will be enough ethical health data users to support Unity Health Score!

This is an intriguing company with a sophisticated strategy–but one with obstacles to overcome. We can all learn from the challenges they face, because many others who want to succeed in the field of health care reform will come up against those challenges.

About the author

Andy Oram

Andy Oram

Andy Oram is an editor at O'Reilly Media, a highly respected book publisher and technology information provider. An employee of the company since 1992, Andy currently specializes in open source, software engineering, and health IT, but his editorial output has ranged from a legal guide covering intellectual property to a graphic novel about teenage hackers. His articles have appeared often on EMR & EHR and other blogs in the health IT space.

Andy also writes often for O'Reilly's Radar site (http://oreilly.com/) and other publications on policy issues related to the Internet and on trends affecting technical innovation and its effects on society. Print publications where his work has appeared include The Economist, Communications of the ACM, Copyright World, the Journal of Information Technology & Politics, Vanguardia Dossier, and Internet Law and Business. Conferences where he has presented talks include O'Reilly's Open Source Convention, FISL (Brazil), FOSDEM, and DebConf.

1 Comment

  • We’ve got updated the phrases and situations of our Rocket Lawyer On Name® Service Degree Settlement
    that apply to your use of the platform and services offered by Rocket Lawyer.
    Subletting, alternatively, is seen as a neater option to get a
    spot to stay medium to long term in New York, with out some of
    the hefty commitment involved in taking over a lease your self.
    Subject to any notice required by regulation, a tenancy at may even involves an finish
    when both the owner or the tenant acts inconsistently with a tenancy.
    A landlord’s notice of hire increase have to be in writing.
    These private leases, which might go for $60 to a whole lot
    of dollars per night in Toronto, supply an alternative to greater-priced accommodations and supply a extra intimate trip expertise, because many ‘hosts’ stay in the
    units and serve as tour guides.

    If your lease initially had two or extra tenants, you
    may have an additional roommate or roommates supplied that the overall variety of tenants and occupants (excluding occupant’s dependent children)
    doesn’t exceed the variety of tenants on the original
    lease. For house leases, the landlord is commonly an condo advanced or a rental company.
    The owner must proceed to perform all duties owed to the tenant — whether or not below
    the original lease or District legislation — together with sustaining the premises
    in compliance with the housing code. Let vb. – To offer (property) for lease; to lease
    out. The sublease is the settlement between the first tenant and the subtenant.

    However, if market prices have elevated because the original lease was
    signed, the sublessor would possibly be capable to safe the next lease value than what is owed the original
    lessor. Reasonable objections to a potential subtenant would possibly embrace concern about his capability to pay the lease, or concern about his
    intention to make use of the premises for unsuitable functions (Julian v.
    Christopher, 320 Md. 1 (1990) Overruled by Waller v.
    Maryland National Bank, 95 Md. App. For example, when you lease your condo to another individual, you’d be creating
    a sublease. Since you could have restricted or no tenants’
    rights towards the landlord in lots of of these cases, you could end up
    being evicted on short discover or coping with other points based on your illegal
    standing.

    You might be additionally liable if the subtenant does not pay their lease or causes harm to the property.
    Rental Worth – Unfortunately, it can be tough to
    lease your apartment out for its full rental price, so you might have
    to ask for a price that is 70-80% of your normal lease.
    Rental deposit: Rental deposit (also referred to as safety
    deposit) is simply required when expressly agreed within the rental agreement.
    When a tenant transfers less than the remaining term or
    lower than the tenant’s complete estate, thus leaving the unique tenant
    with a reversionary interest within the lease,
    the switch is a sublease.

    For example, the girlfriend of a tenant may be
    a subtenant if she lives together with her boyfriend (the tenant)
    but has not signed the lease or rental agreement.

    If you wish to relet your condo, the condominium group could have the replacement
    resident sign a brand new lease, releasing you from your entire obligations as a renter
    of that condominium. The shareholder, Mr. Neary said, in an effort to compensate the
    subtenant for the anticipated inconvenience of having the
    house shown to potential buyers, allowed the tenant to
    remain within the apartment at a less-than-market-value hire after the lease expired.

    Property, particularly an apartment, rented by a tenant to a different party.

    If there’s even the remotest possibility you may must sublet your condo, ask the landlord about it prematurely.
    If he does not approve the tenant inside that point period, then you possibly can file for a
    decrease in companies at the Lease Board. To sublet (sublease) is to lease to
    a different person a home or apartment that is already being leased to you.
    Many will allow subletting, because the apply helps them avoid folks
    breaking their lease or leaving the condominium
    early. Moreover, leases for unregulated tenants protect against surprising rent will increase during the time period
    of the lease. 6. Neither your roommate nor your roommate’s dependent youngsters acquire any proper
    to remain in the residence if the named tenant(s) vacate the condominium.

    For example, your subtenant will have to request repairs to the condo
    from you. Create your sublet settlement, get rent, and extra.
    Whereas 1000’s of people have successfully used Pennlets to lease out a
    spot or discover a place to sublet, like anywhere on the web, there can sometimes be unscrupulous individuals attempting to rip-off unsuspecting customers.
    The property proprietor typically is not responsible for damage to your belongings, so consider getting Renters Insurance
    coverage. Unfortunately, the legislation that enables the landlord to require cash funds doesn’t clearly answer these questions.
    Discover out about renting versus subletting with help from an actual estate professional on this free
    video clip.

    In New York state, for example, the regulation says that house
    owners of buildings with four or extra items can’t unreasonably refuse a tenant’s request to sublet
    an apartment. Subletting could be helpful if a good-standing tenant has a respectable cause for their absence from
    the house and the landlord want to proceed the relationship when the tenant returns,” says Homapour.
    When you have a periodic rental settlement ,your landlord
    can increase your rent, but the landlord must offer you correct
    advance notice in writing. The individual or entity subleasing space from the
    primary tenant is known as a subtenant or
    sublessee.

    A sublease can apply to the entire unit or just a portion of
    it. For those who’re living with a roommate and that
    particular person’s identify is the one one on the lease, then you could be a subtenant underneath your local legal guidelines.
    After getting your landlord’s permission to sublet your rental,
    make sure to summarize your settlement in writing.
    Thus, from the landlord’s perspective, it is crucial for the lease to provide that the tenant remains liable, a minimum of for the preliminary lease obligations, regardless of
    any later modification of the lease phrases.
    For example, a pupil may sign a lease with a one-year term, and then sublet the rental property throughout the
    summer time break when he goes away for a trip.

    You at the moment are known as the sublandlord,
    and the new tenant turns into the subtenant. However, if the property proprietor unreasonably” withholds approval, you
    can be launched from your lease after providing thirty days notice.

    Once you have authorised a sub-tenant, create a sublease agreement and have all events involved
    signal it, together with all tenants from the unique lease and
    the brand new sub-tenant. For example, in case you have
    a month-to-month rental settlement, so does the subtenant.
    Complexity can arise when the first enterprise owner is renting the house.
    The unique landlord and tenant under a lease have both privity of property and privity of contract.

    By assigning or sub-letting the lease to a third
    social gathering, tenants can go away the property with out breaking the phrases of their lease or paying two
    units of lease. Your lease settlement could require that
    you simply get permission from your landlord to sublease your rental unit.

    Subletting – You’ll be able to sublet the condominium if
    you have to, but following the proper procedures is crucial.
    Rental buildings are normally extra stubborn as they prefer
    to maintain the lease phrases standard. Slaby v. DC Rental Housing Fee PDF, 685 A.2nd 1166 (1996) – Sublessor was statutorily prohibited from charging
    subtenants more lease than she paid to her landlord even if she paid utility and repair expenses related to rental
    units; sublessor could not bear those expenses and pass them on to subtenants in form of rent.

    Subletting is a chance for the 3 months the unit could also be unoccupied.
    The same concerns apply regarding the landlord’s proper to withhold its consent to a proposed switch of the lease apply to
    the landlord’s right to withhold its consent to a proposed change in a tenant’s (or its transferee’s) use of the house.
    In a complete sublease, where permitted, the subtenant basically replaces the original tenant.
    If the landlord isn’t willing to forgive or decrease the
    late payment, ask the owner to justify it (for instance, by way of administrative prices for processing the fee late).
    But this varies relying on the arrangement the property manager has
    made with the unique renter.

    It would rely in your line of enterprise, the present availability of subleases or direct workplace leases in your area, what lease terms you might be looking for out and how a
    lot each kind of lease arrangement will value you. The unique
    tenant has not relinquished her proper to return to
    the unit, nonetheless, so you need to serve a discover
    of rent increase on the unique tenant, with
    a copy to the subtenant. If the unit is below lease
    management, District regulation prohibits the tenant from charging the subtenant any
    more lease than the tenant is charged by the owner.
    Savvy landlords need all occupants of a rental unit to signal
    a lease or rental agreement and usually prohibit subtenants without the owner’s written consent.

    The chain has been reconfiguring one other 200 stores, with
    the concept of subletting or promoting space to outside firms.
    If your landlord consents, chances are you’ll sublease, but you remain responsible for future rents.
    If a tenant desires to depart their premises earlier than the holiday date specified
    in their lease settlement, they will assign (i.e.
    transfer) or sub-let the shopfront. Complete a sublease utility – You and
    your subletter will need to fill out a sublease addendum
    and sublease utility and give it to your landlord.
    In order for the original tenant to avoid this responsibility, the landlord, the unique tenant, and the
    brand new tenant all should agree that the new tenant might be
    solely responsible to the owner under the assignment.

    You’ll usually even discover that landlords choose to terminate a lease ASAP and have you vacate
    the condo somewhat than making the repairs themselves. In case your landlord agrees in writing, you can lease your condominium to another particular
    person. Like a sublease clause, there should also be a press release in the original commercial lease addressing whether or not a tenant can assign the rest
    of a lease to a 3rd occasion. The original tenant, or first
    lessee, retains some or all rights beneath the original lease or
    grasp lease. A contract obligates the tenant
    to pay month-to-month rent through the rental interval.

    The classification of a leasehold switch as an assignment or sublease carries differing authorized implications concerning future legal
    responsibility arising beneath the prime lease. In authorized phrases, the landlord is the lessor, the tenant
    is the lessee, and the sublessee is renting from the lessee.
    A rental could delineate the rights and obligations of
    each of those. At the similar time, Mr. Shmulewitz said, there’ll undoubtedly be conditions where a shareholder’s want or must sublet an apartment is reasonable.

    If the landlord permits subletting, or if the lease doesn’t prohibit subletting,
    it’s the landlord’s possibility whether to permit
    assignment or novation. http://kyoto.pro.tok2.com/bbs7-a-150815/no3/yybbs.cgi

Click here to post a comment
   

Categories